Medical Experts Request the Reassessment of Pneumo Vax
In a recent forum, UP-CPH Dean and Centre Director Dr. Vicente Belizario, Jr. said that there is a need to revisit the national strategy for pneumococcal conjugate vaccine (PCV) and update the national formulary in the country which can affect the response to the continuing public health challenge posed by pneumonia.
“A strong national immunization program is one that is open to new scientific evidence for continuing enhancement of policy and service delivery,” he pointed out.
Medical experts led by researchers from the University of the Philippines College of Public Health (UP-CPH), the Southeast Asian Ministers of Education Organization Tropical Medicine and Public Health Regional Centre for Public Health, Hospital Administration, Environmental and Occupational Health (SEAMEO TROPMED Philippines), called for a review of the 10-year-old pneumonia vaccine strategy in order to protect children against one of the leading killer diseases for kids. The Philippines is ranked 5th worldwide in having the most number of pneumonia deaths.
The University of the Philippines College of Public Health (UP CPH) recently held the webinar “Opportunities to Access Pneumococcal Vaccine in the Philippines” on creating greater Pneumococcal Conjugate Vaccine (PCV) coverage for the country. Upper row, from left: Dr. Lulu Bravo, Executive Director, Philippine Foundation for Vaccination and Convenor of the Vaccine Solidarity Movement; Dr. Vicente Y. Belizario, Jr., Dean and Centre Director, College of Public Health, University of the Philippines Manila, SEAMEO TROPMED; and Dr. Maria Rosario Z. Capeding, Pediatrician, Infectious Disease Specialist, Asian Hospital and Medical Center. Bottom row, from left: Dr. Maria Margarita M. Lota, Project Leader, Assistant Professor and Chair, Department of Medical Microbiology, UP-CPH; and ANC anchor and event moderator Mimi Ong.
The highlight of the forum was the dissemination of the results of a new UP-CPH study which concluded that “a reassessment of PCV use in the National Immunization Program (NIP) with the inclusion of all three pneumonia vaccine formulations may be warranted.”
“We now have PCV choices that will provide us greater access and protection for more Filipino children. So let us have new available evidence for our health policy and decision-makers to consider when they reassess our vaccines being included in the NIP,” said research project leader and UP-CPH Department of Medical Microbiology Assistant Professor and Chair, Dr. Maria Margarita Lota.
Health experts representing the Department of Health (DOH), the Philippine Foundation for Vaccination, and the Vaccine Solidarity Movement joined the forum where considerations for all three WHO recommended PCV vaccines were proposed for the NIP based on current evidence.
Revisiting vaccine strategy
Since 2009, vaccines have been available for invasive pneumococcal disease (IPD) caused by Streptococcus pneumoniae in infants and children from 6 weeks up to 2 years of age. However, pneumococcal pneumonia remains to be the number one cause of death in infants and young children under five, and third overall across all ages, next only to cardiac diseases and cancer. According to UNICEF, pneumonia takes one child every 39 seconds.
The three WHO-approved vaccines – PCV13 and two kinds of PCV10: PHiD-CV and SIIL-PCV – differ in their direct protection to serotypes or variations of the bacteria. PCV13, the NIP’s current vaccine, was recommended by the Formulary Executive Council in 2014 based on the locally relevant serotypes.
However, according to WHO, evidence suggests that there has been a substantial change in the epidemiology of pneumococcal disease; this provides the basis for a review of the choice of vaccine with possible consideration of the ones that offer proven direct protection against the prevailing serotypes.
“Epidemiology is changing all the time,” said Dr. Rose Capeding, Pediatrician and Infectious Disease Specialist at the Asian Hospital and Medical Center. Her presentation included epidemiological data showing that in 2020, 100 serotypes of the bacteria that cause pneumococcal pneumonia have been identified.
The value of direct protection
The study added that direct protection is better than cross-protection, which is offered by a vaccine to serotypes of the same species but with minor differences in their genetic makeup. “Direct protection against current pneumococcal serotypes is more effective than cross-protection, and WHO recommends direct inclusion of specific serotypes for vaccines in certain settings,” said Lota.
The study also considers the economics of PCVs, citing the “potential savings from using a new and possibly more cost-effective formulation, the cost of averting resistant serotypes, and the availability of a new PCV with a different but comparable serotype coverage and lowest vaccine price.”
“Knowing all the evidence for the three PCVs, we can see that they are comparable. This means that we can now include these three choices so we can have greater access and availability for the NIP as well as for the private sector,” said Lota.
The UP-CPH study recommended that the Health Technology Assessment Council (HTAC), the DOH’s independent advisory board on funding health interventions and technologies, may consider doing its own survey. It cited as reasons “new formulations with a lower vaccine price and a different rate of reduction in the number of cases and deaths averted.”
Ultimately, the accessibility of all three WHO-approved PCVs in the country and the advantages they bring can elevate the healthcare system in the Philippines to be at par with other GAVI-vetted countries that have all three WHO-approved vaccines in their national formularies.
Dr. Lulu Bravo, Executive Director of the Philippine Foundation for Vaccination and Convenor of the Vaccine Solidarity Movement, emphasized the importance of immunization: “Prevention tops everything else. If you prevent disease, you will prevent our healthcare system from being overwhelmed. Immunization is at the core of disease prevention. If we focus more on primary healthcare which includes vaccines, we can prevent diseases. We start at the pediatric level,” she said.
Earlier, Congress signed House Resolution (HR) 2492 which called for an investigation of pneumonia vaccines in the country and the economic implications of using only PCV13, when a less expensive option, PCV10 with two formularies, is also available. The WHO had declared that both PCV 10 and PCV 13 are at parity and not inferior to each other. However, to date, only PCV13 is currently available in the Philippine National Immunization Program.